Driving Evaluation Tools - #42
Take QuizLearn the basic medical requirements for safe driving and the components of clinical evaluation.
Safe Driving Requires….
-
Memory
-
Concentration
-
Adequate motor and cognitive response time
-
Visual perception, visual processing, and visuospatial skills
-
Executive function
-
Mental flexibility/multitasking
-
Physical strength, coordination, and flexibility
-
Adequate hearing
-
Adequate vision
-
VALID DRIVERS LICENSE
Red Flags for Increased Risk of Unsafe Driving:
►Medical Conditions:
-
Dementia
-
Hearing Impairment
-
Seizures
-
Psychosis
-
Alcoholism
-
Cardiac disease
-
Parkinson’s disease
-
Diabetes
-
Visual Impairment
-
Arthritis
-
Obstructive Sleep Apnea
-
Cerebrovascular disease
Table 1: Examples of medical conditions can adversely affect driving ability:
System |
Conditions |
Effects on driving |
Cardiovascular |
Myocardial infarction |
US Dept of Transportation Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration mandates that commercial motor vehicle drivers must be evaluated by a cardiologist prior to returning to work after an acute MI |
|
Arrhythmia |
Episodes of loss of consciousness associated with arrhythmia |
|
Syncope |
Loss of consciousness |
Endocrine |
Diabetes |
Hypoglycemia may impair concentration and judgment |
Neurologic |
Seizure |
Typically cannot drive for 3-6 months after a seizure.(Varies by state) http://www.epilepsyfoundation.org/resources/Driving-Laws-by-State.cfm |
|
Neuropathy |
Decreased sensation for pedals |
|
Stroke |
Weakness and other post-stroke deficits |
|
Dementia |
Does not necessarily preclude driving however, needs frequent assessments for impairment in judgment and visuospatial abilities. |
Pulmonary |
Apnea |
Falling asleep at the wheel |
|
Others |
Decreased oxygen delivery to central nervous system |
Musculoskeletal |
Arthritis, PMR |
Weakness, pain and joint stiffness may limit patient’s ability to turn head, control vehicle |
Substance abuse |
|
Impaired driving ability. Some older patients do not consider drinking and driving to be problematic. |
►Medications:
-
Opiates
-
Muscle Relaxants
-
Hypnotics
-
Tricyclic antidepressants
-
Antipsychotics
-
Antihistamines
-
Insulin
-
Anticholinergics
-
Anticonvulsants
-
Antiemetics
-
Antihypertensives
-
Stimulants
-
Glaucoma agents
PEARL: Don’t forget about the dangers of polypharmacy as these classes of medications can have an additive effect on impaired driving ability when combined.
►Review of Systems:
-
General:
-
Weakness, fatigue
-
-
HEENT:
-
Impaired vision, vertigo, head trauma, hearing loss
-
-
Respiratory:
-
Shortness of breath, use of oxygen
-
-
Cardiac:
-
Syncope, palpations, chest pain, dyspnea on exertion
-
-
Musculoskeletal:
-
Muscle weakness, muscle pain, joint pain, decreased range of motion
-
-
Neurologic:
-
Dizziness, seizures, focal weakness, tremors, decreased sensation, numbness, memory loss
-
-
Psychiatric:
-
Depression, anxiety, psychosis, substance abuse
-
►Concern of impaired driving by "informant" (patient, family member, friend…):
►Hx of traffic crashes, near misses, tickets, and/or episodes of getting lost while driving
►Caregiver’s perception of impaired driving skills
Ask your patient:
-
Do other drivers honk or pass you frequently, even when traffic is moving relatively slow?
-
Do you become nervous or anxious when approaching intersections?
-
Do you arrive at a location and not remember how you got there?
-
Do you notice dents and dings on your vehicle and do not know how they got there?
-
Have you found yourself in more close calls and near misses on the road?
-
Do family or friends comment negatively on your driving habits?
Ask the family/friend:
-
Would you feel safe riding with….?
-
Would you allow your children/pet to ride with ….?
Key Components of Clinical Evaluation:
-
Visual acuity and visual fields
-
Hearing
-
Range of motion:
-
Neck
-
Shoulder
-
Elbow
-
Plantar flexion/dorsiflexion
-
-
Motor strength:
-
Shoulder adduction, abduction, and flexion
-
Wrist flexion/ extension
-
Hand grip strength
-
Hip flexion and extension
-
Ankle dorsiflexion and plantar flexion
-
-
Sensory:
-
Light touch
-
Proprioception
-
-
Rapid Pace Walk:
-
Patient walks 10 feet in one direction, turns around, and walks back to starting place as quickly as possible
-
Scores greater than 9 seconds are abnormal and have been found to have a threefold increased risk of being in an at fault traffic accident
-
-
Cognitive Screening:
-
Clock Draw: Assess the patients executive skills, attention, abstract thinking, visual perception, visuospatial skills, long term memory, and short term memory
-
Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MOCA): Assess attention, executive function, visualspatial , memory
-
Trails B: Assess working memory, visual processing, visuospatial skills, selected and divided attention, and psychomotor coordination
-
Elderly patient whom you suspect has impaired driving ability
Identify/Evaluate for risk factors for impaired driving and facilitate driving cessation.
Driving is one of the most complex skills that we perform. The ability to safely drive can be affected by ones mental, physical, and emotional conditions. According to both AAA and AARP, most people currently driving should expect to outlive their driving ability by 5-10 years. Per mile driven the fatality rate for drivers over 85 years old is 9 times greater than all other age groups except teenagers and young adults. In 2010, drivers over age 65 accounted for 17% of all traffic fatalities and 8% of all people injured in traffic accidents. In fact, motor vehicle injures are the leading cause of injury –related deaths in adults older than 65. The majority of traffic fatalities involving older drivers in 2010, occurred in the daytime (77%), weekdays (71%), and involved other vehicles (66%).
Science Principles
-
Review the basic medical requirements for safe driving
-
List red flags for increased risk of unsafe driving
-
Review key components of clinical evaluation of individuals that you suspect to be at high risk of impaired driving
-
Review of Systems (ROS)
Geriatric Topics
ACGME Compentencies
Science Principles
-
Physician’s Guide to Assessing and Counseling Older Drivers. Carr DB, Schwartzberg JG, Manning L, Sempek J. editors. American Medical Association. 2010. http://geriatricscareonline.org/ProductAbstract/physicians-guide-to-assessing-and-counseling-older-drivers/B013
-
Carr DB. The Older Adult Driver. Am Fam Physician. 2000; 61:141-146.
-
Edwards JD, Bart E, O’Connor ML, Cissell G. Ten Years Down the Road: Predictors of Driving Cessation. The Gerontologist. 2009; 50:393-399.
-
Edwards JD, Lunsman M, Perkins M, Rebok GW, Roth DL. Driving Cessation and Health Trajectories in Older Adults. Journal of Gerontology A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2009; 64:1290-1295.
-
http://www.cdc.gov/Motorvehiclesafety/Older_Adult_Drivers/adult-drivers_factsheet.html
-
http://www.nhtsa.gov/people/injury/olddrive/safe/safe-toc.htm
Users are free to download and distribute Geriatric Fast Facts for informational, educational, and research purposes only. Citation: http://www.geriatricfastfacts.com/fast-facts/driving-evaluation-tools. See Terms of Use for additional information.
Disclaimer: Geriatric Fast Facts are for informational, educational and research purposes only. Geriatric Fast Facts are not, nor are they intended to be, medical advice. Health care providers should exercise their own independent clinical judgment when diagnosing and treating patients. Some Geriatric Fast Facts cite the use of a product in a dosage, for an indication, or in a manner other than that recommended in the product labeling. Accordingly, the official prescribing information should be consulted before any such product is used.
Terms of Use: Geriatric Fast Facts are provided for informational, educational and research purposes only. Use of the material for any other purpose constitutes infringement of the copyright and intellectual property rights owned by the specific authors and/or their affiliated institutions listed on each Fast Fact. By using any of this material, you assume all risks of copyright infringement and related liability. Geriatric Fast Facts may not be reproduced or used for unauthorized purposes without prior written permission, which may be obtained by submitting a written request to: Medical College of Wisconsin, Dept. of Medicine, Division of Geriatrics and Gerontology, 8701 Watertown Plank Road, Milwaukee, WI 53226. Note the Geriatric Fast Facts may contain copyrighted work created under contract with government agencies, foundations, funding organizations and commercial companies, etc. If a particular author places further restrictions on the material, you must honor those restrictions regardless of whether such restrictions are described in this mobile app.